Experienced Kansas City Construction Law Firm

Judge refuses to dismiss Pepsi Cola ad copyright case

On Behalf of | Sep 28, 2017 | Contract Disputes

Missouri residents may know that companies spend hundreds of millions of dollars each year to advertise their products during the Super Bowl. The game’s halftime extravaganza generally features top performers and Hollywood-level production values, and companies with huge marketing budgets often clamor for the few advertising spots available. Pepsi Cola paid for such an ad during the 2016 Super Bowl halftime show to promote its brand and attract new customers, but the decision has left the company mired in a copyright dispute with a Connecticut-based advertising agency.

The advertising agency claims in its lawsuit that it came up with the idea of an ad using a human jukebox performing songs from various decades and musical genres. The agency alleges that Pepsi refused to pay the agreed $5,000 for the concept before shooting the commercial using the soul singer and actress Janelle Moore. Reports suggest that Pepsi had a change of heart and agreed to pay the $5,000 when news emerged that an intellectual property infringement lawsuit was being prepared, but the agency chose to reject the offer of payment and proceed with the legal action.

Lawyers representing Pepsi filed a motion to dismiss the copyright infringement lawsuit on the basis that its claims of unfair competition, unjust enrichment and conversion were preempted by the 1976 Copyright Act. The New York federal judge hearing the case accepted some of these argument but refused to dismiss the case. The judge pointed out that there was enough similarity between the agency concept and the finished commercial to warrant legal questions, and he gave the agency 30 days to file an amended complaint.

Intellectual property cases can be difficult and costly to litigate, and attorneys with business and contract law experience may urge their clients to settle such legal battles quickly or avoid them altogether. Attorneys could also encourage their clients to regularly review their intellectual property to ensure that it is properly protected.

Testimonials

“Long & Robinson was in our corner from the beginning through the end, giving great advice and guidance, and working with us to bring our issue to resolution. Would highly recommend for construction representation.”

— Jeff Wasinger, Vice President – Haren Companies

Testimonials

“Burke Robinson and the Long & Robinson law firm were a pleasure to work with and were also excellent in every way. The firm fully supported a contentious claim, providing guidance and insight at every turn. Although it’s challenging for an organization, as the plaintiffs, to maintain a positive feeling throughout a lengthy process, Mr. Robinson and his team continued to offer encouragement with helpful legal analysis and reporting. A critical part of reporting and case management is a detailed review, understanding and strategy for the complex elements of a claim such as ours and Mr. Robinson demonstrated that in abundance. I highly recommend Long & Robinson to any organization that needs the same kind of legal team as we did.”

— Chris Durkin, Director – One Park Place Tower Condominium Association

Testimonials

“Burke has been absolutely amazing to work with. I feel we have a very unique situation that is rather hard to explain and put all of the pieces together. Burke has been amazing at assisting our HOA and addressing all of our questions in a quick and professional manner. If he doesn’t know the answer he finds it and responds quickly. I would recommend Burke to anyone in need of legal services. Our HOA is extremely happy we found him!”

Testimonials

“I was in the construction business for 40 years. In that time I have had the need for legal help a few times. This firm provided expertise and service that was light years beyond others law offices. We COULD NOT have done better. Thank you so much.”

Testimonials

“We looked at many options and selected Long Robinson based on reputation and our interviews. Burke Robinson has proven to be a great choice.”